Xiaomi 17 vs Honor Magic8
Verdict
Xiaomi 17 and Honor Magic8 are evenly matched for most people
Overall score
Why pick Xiaomi 17
- 3 h 21 min longer battery life Estimated
- 8K 30fps video recording (vs 4K 60fps)
- Brighter main camera lens (f/1.7 vs f/1.9)
Why pick Honor Magic8
- 32% cheaper
- Brighter screen (6000 nits vs 1087 nits) Maker's figure against a lab test
- Better water resistance: IP69 vs IP68
Honor Magic8 is slightly better for gaming
Overall score
Why pick Xiaomi 17
- 3 h 21 min longer battery life Estimated
Why pick Honor Magic8
- Brighter screen (6000 nits vs 1087 nits) Maker's figure against a lab test
- 32% cheaper
- Better water resistance: IP69 vs IP68
Xiaomi 17 and Honor Magic8 are evenly matched for photos and video
Overall score
Why pick Xiaomi 17
- 8K 30fps video recording (vs 4K 60fps)
- Brighter main camera lens (f/1.7 vs f/1.9)
- 3 h 21 min longer battery life Estimated
Why pick Honor Magic8
- 32% cheaper
- Brighter screen (6000 nits vs 1087 nits) Maker's figure against a lab test
- Better water resistance: IP69 vs IP68
Xiaomi 17 and Honor Magic8 are evenly matched for battery life
Overall score
Why pick Xiaomi 17
- 3 h 21 min longer battery life Estimated
- 8K 30fps video recording (vs 4K 60fps)
- Brighter main camera lens (f/1.7 vs f/1.9)
Why pick Honor Magic8
- 32% cheaper
- Brighter screen (6000 nits vs 1087 nits) Maker's figure against a lab test
- Better water resistance: IP69 vs IP68
Honor Magic8 is much better for the money
Overall score
Why pick Xiaomi 17
- 3 h 21 min longer battery life Estimated
- 8K 30fps video recording (vs 4K 60fps)
- Brighter main camera lens (f/1.7 vs f/1.9)
Why pick Honor Magic8
- 32% cheaper
- Brighter screen (6000 nits vs 1087 nits) Maker's figure against a lab test
- Better water resistance: IP69 vs IP68
Scores by category
- Xiaomi 17
- Honor Magic8
Performance
98 Xiaomi 17 98 Honor Magic8Lab testedTypical for its chipsetDisplay
86 Xiaomi 17 99 Honor Magic8Lab testedCamera
95 Xiaomi 17 87 Honor Magic8Battery
99 Xiaomi 17 95 Honor Magic8Lab testedEstimatedBuild and durability
56 Xiaomi 17 59 Honor Magic8Connectivity and features
94 Xiaomi 17 94 Honor Magic8
Biggest differences
See all specsSize and weight
- Xiaomi 17
- Honor Magic8
Full specs
General
Design
Frame: Aluminum
Front: Xiaomi Dragon Crystal Glass
Display
68 billion colors
Capacitive Touchscreen
Dolby Vision
HDR10+
HDR Vivid
Multi-touch display
4320Hz PWM Dimming
Capacitive Touchscreen
Dolby Vision
HDR image support
HDR Vivid
Multi-touch display
Hardware
6x 3.62 GHz – Oryon V3 Phoenix M
6x 3.62 GHz – Oryon V3 Phoenix M
512GB 12GB RAM
512GB 16GB RAM
1TB 16GB RAM
512GB 12GB RAM
512GB 16GB RAM
1TB 16GB RAM
Benchmarks
Software
Main camera
Optical Image Stabilization (OIS)
Optical Image Stabilization (OIS)
PDAF (10cm - ∞)
PDAF
High Dynamic Range (HDR)
Laser Autofocus
Leica lens
Panorama
High Dynamic Range (HDR)
Panorama
2160p @ 30/60 fps
1080p @ 30/60/120/240/960 fps
720p @ 1920 fps
1080p @ 24/30/60/120/240 fps
Front camera
Panorama
1080p @ 30/60 fps
1080p @ 30/60 fps
Battery
7000 mAh (China)
Reverse wireless charging
Reverse wireless charging
Network
Dual SIM (Nano-SIM + Nano-SIM + eSIM + eSIM)
Connectivity
DisplayPort
USB On-The-Go
DisplayPort 1.2
USB On-The-Go
Multimedia
Features
Barometer
Compass
Gyroscope
Proximity sensor
Ultrasonic under-display fingerprint sensor
Compass
Gyroscope
Proximity sensor
Ultrasonic under-display fingerprint sensor
Quick Charge 3+
USB Power Delivery 3.0
Programmable Power Supply (PPS)
Universal Fast Charging Specification (UFCS)
Lab tests
EU energy label
These phones share every spec listed here.
Compare with other phones
How scores work
Each category score shows where a phone stands among phones launched in the last two years: 80 means it beats 80% of them. Scores move as new phones arrive.
Benchmarks, battery and brightness come from lab tests when the phone was tested. Otherwise the scores use results typical for its chipset, or an estimate from its specifications, and say so.
The camera score rates the hardware (sensor size, lens brightness, stabilization, zoom and video), not the photos themselves.
Small differences people would not notice, such as 120 Hz against 144 Hz, never count as a win. Size and weight are shown but never scored, because bigger is a preference.
Value compares a phone's overall score with what phones at the same price usually score. Phones launched more than three years ago get no value score, because their listed prices are usually used or clearance prices.


